BEEF · Cut · Compare

Round vs Shank

Two cuts people weigh against each other at the counter — here is what actually separates them.

Side by side

RoundShank
Tenderness 36 26
Marbling 22 30
Umami 62 80
Price 34 30

Round

Topside & silverside · tende de tranche · tapa

The hind leg. It works hard for a living, so it carries almost no fat and the highest protein density on the carcass. That is exactly why raw beef dishes are cut from here.

60°CSous vide preferred

For anything served raw, buy from a counter that can tell you the slaughter date and choose the clearest, brightest colour.

Explore →

Shank

Shin · jarret · osso buco

Leg muscle, and essentially a block of collagen. Under pressure or in a sous vide bath it converts completely into gelatin, at which point a spoon will cut it.

Pressure 40 minCook it right through

Look for tendon that is translucent rather than chalky, and meat that springs back when pressed.

Explore →

Which one to buy

  • Better forRound : Shank
  • Raw beef dishesRound90 : —
  • Braised in soyAbout the same85 : 90
  • JerkyRound70 : —
  • StewsShank— : 85
  • Bone brothShank— : 75

Other comparisons

All cuts

← Back to the chart

Temperatures are guidance for whole-muscle cuts. Ground meat and poultry need 71°C / 160°F throughout.